As one drives down West College Avenue in Jacksonville,
Illinois, the campus of Illinois College is a quite stunning
sight with its historically significant Beecher Hall, collection
of more modern brick buildings, and spacious commons. Yet, the
college was not always there. Residents of Jacksonville with any
connection to the college talk about the work of "The Yale Band."
It is somewhat of a local legend that a group of young men should
have come out from New England in the 1820s and 1830s to what was
then a sparsely settled frontier in order to establish the first
college in the state of Illinois. What circumstances moved these
men to leave the comforts of New England for the rigors of the
prairie? How did they begin the work of establishing the college?
Their story is not a simple one.
In 1801, the Congregationalists and Presbyterians formed an
agreement which they called the plan of union. Under this
agreement, members of both denominations worked together in the
mission fields of the frontier. In 1825, it was under this
agreement that New Englander John Ellis, a Congregationalist
minister and Dartmouth alumnus, came to Illinois to devote his
life to mission work.
What Ellis found was a state where education, even among the
Protestant clergy, was limited and generally undervalued. Peter
Cartwright, remembered locally as an early Methodist circuit
riding preacher who ironically enough helped establish what is
now known as MacMurray College, remarked that he was glad that he
hadn't wasted four years in college. Schools of any sort were
rare in Illinois. The Catholics had established some parochial
and boarding schools in the southern part of the state. There
were scattered "blab" schools which operated by subscription,
usually on a barter basis. There is often a docent in the
reconstructed rough hewn log school/Church building at New Salem
State Park near Petersburg, Illinois. Sitting through his
presentation gives one a feeling for the true primitiveness of
the education system in Illinois during this period of time, in
which a schoolmaster could have as little as the modern
equivalent of a third grade education. The course of study at
these schools was limited to spelling, reading, writing, and some
basic arithmetic, with all of the students reciting their lessons
together aloud. Yet Ellis' overriding goal was not the reform
of the education system, but the spread of the Evangelical
Protestant brand of Christianity.
In order to do that, Ellis felt that there was a need for the
establishment of a seminary for young men to equip them for the
ministry. He enlisted the support of the settlers at Shoal Creek
who had already set up a board of governors for an institution
they were ready to call "Fairfield Literary and Theological
Seminary." He had the support of the Presbytery for the work of
establishing a seminary. Yet, in travelling about the state with
his friend the Quaker Thomas Lippincott, Ellis decided that
Jacksonville was a far more suitable location than Shoal Creek
for the seminary. Ellis purchased a quarter section of ground,
one mile west of Jacksonville just east of Wilson grove and a
mile north of Diamond Grove. The Shoal Creek group was extremely
angry. Ellis had grossly exceeded the limits of his authority to
spend the group's money. The Presbytery withdrew their support
from the project.
So, he had the land for his school, but without the
continuing support of the Presbytery and without the continuing
base of support from Shoal Creek. Since one cannot have a
theological seminary without the graduates thereof being
acredited by some religious body, Ellis was in a quandry. About
this time, he was called to the pastorate of the newly organized
Presbyterian Church in Jacksonville. During this time, he decided
that the professors of theology of the seminary would be chosen
by Presbyterian clergymen. He also began to circulate a
subscription paper through Morgan County for the support of this
college which was yet in the idea stage. This drive netted some
$1913 in pledges payable in both cash and goods as well as two
tracts of land. In September 1828, Ellis wrote an article for
the Home Missionary, a publication of the American Home
Missionary Society, describing his work at the church in
Jacksonville and outlining his hope for the founding of the
college.
This article sparked the interest of a group of young men at
Yale. These young men were Theron Baldwin, John F. Brooks, Mason
Grosvenor, Elisha Jenney, William Kirby, Julian M. Sturtevant,
and Asa Turner, Jr. Grosvenor, in New Haven, wrote a letter to
Ellis, in Jacksonville, dated December 5, 1828 exploring the
possibility of this group of men merging their vision with that
of Ellis. He wrote:
"My object in writing is to obtain some information
respecting the Western country. The moral condition of its
inhabitants is a subject which has occupied many of my thoughts
and I trust called forth the feelings of my heart. To think of
the present number of immortal souls within our own country--
living on trial for an endless destiny, is deeply affecting: But
to think of their rapid increase in a situation where little or
no light shines to invite them to invite them to the world of
felicity or to warn them of that dark abyss to which they rapidly
hasten is truly overwhelming. What more can be done to give them
the light of the Gospel has for some time past been the subject
of my investigations. Among a few in this Seminary the subject
has been discussed and I think some plan of effort will soon be
adopted by them... One of their first objects would be to
establish a seminary of learning where in due time young men may
acquire a thorough education both collegiate and theological, and
thus be prepared for the ministry... Some quantity of land might
also be owned by the Seminary in order to afford manual labor for
the students... In order to accomplish this object, funds must be
raised. But the proclibility [sic] of raising funds in this
region we feel little doubt. It will be necessary too that the
individuals who engage in such an expedition together with the
clergymen now on the ground should have the main control of the
Seminary."
Ellis was evidently quite pleased to get this letter. He replied on January 17, 1829, "As to the plan it gives me pleasure to state that it was originally so framed as to admit the cooperation of the friends at the East; and so as to give them all the control of the institution they could desire if they want to furnish the fund."
On February 21, 1829, the group of young men at Yale met and
drew up a compact or solemn pledge for their proposed work in
Illinois. It is an interesting document:
"Believing in the entire alienation of the natural heart from
God, in the necessity of the influences of the Holy Spirit for
its renovation, and that these influences are not to be expected
without the use of means; deeply impressed also with the
destitute condition of the western section of our country and the
urgent claims of its inhabitants upon the benevolence of the
East, and in view of the fearful crisis evidently approaching,
and which we believe can only be averted by speedy and energetic
measures on the part of the friends of religion and liturature in
the older states, and believing that evangelical religion and
education must go hand in hand in order to the successful
accomplishment of this desirable object; we the undersigned
hereby express our readiness to go to the state of Illinois for
the purpose of establishing a seminary of learning such as shall
be best adapted to the exigencies of that country- a part of us
to engage as instructors at the seminary- the others to occupy -
as preachers- important stations in the surrounding county-
provided the undertaking be deemed practicable, and the location
approved by intelligent men- and provided also the Providence of
God permit us to engage in it."
This solemn pledge of the aforenamed men was approved on
February 23rd by Nathaniel W. Taylor and Josiah W. Gibbs,
professors respectively of Didactic Theology and Sacred
Literature at Yale. The covenant was also approved by Jeremiah
Day, who was then the President of Yale.
Things began to happen rather quickly. The original group of
seven grew to include Romulus Barnes, Flavel Bascom, William
Carter, Henry Herrick, Benoni Y. Messenger, and Jairus Wilcox.
Julian Sturtevant travelled to New York to discuss the plans for
the seminary with the directors of the American Home Missionary
Society. On March 7, 1829, Grosvenor wrote to Ellis:
"We have now laid before you the terms of the proposed union and the opinions of men well qualified to judge in respect to them...We wish to see an Institution on that spot, where pupils can be fitted for college and for the various departments of active life, and where a thorough collegiate and ultimately professional education may be obtained. All this we do not suppose can be done in a day; but the object of our association will not be accomplished till all this shall be secured, and that too on a foundation so permanent as to be transmitted, as a rich legacy, to succeeding generations."
The Yale band and the trustees of the proposed college in
Illinois came to terms. John Ellis travelled to the east. With
Grosvenor and others, he went to Boston and Andover on a
fundraising drive. One Sunday evening meeting at a Church in New
Haven secured pledges of $1,200. The Yale Band with Ellis
easily raised support of $10,000 for the work of the college. On
April 14, 1829, the American Home Missionary Society appointed
Sturtevant, Baldwin and Turner as missionaries to Illinois.
Meanwhile, back in Illinois the work on the building which would
be known as Beecher Hall was begun. On August 26, 1829, Baldwin
and Sturtevant were ordained to the ministry at Woodbury,
Connecticut. By the end of the month Sturtevant had married his
sweetheart. In October, the now Reverend Mr. Sturtevant and his
bride, along with the Reverend Mr. Baldwin, were in transit to
Illinois. Baldwin remained behind in St. Louis to handle some
matters while Sturtevant hired a team and driver for the last leg
of the journey. They arrived in Jacksonville on Sunday morning,
November 15, 1829. Sturtevant's Autobiography would later relate:
"Most of the houses were covered with boards, split from oak
logs four feet in length and nailed on without shaving. Many
roofs were covered in the same way... The census of 1830 gave
Jacksonville a population of little over 600. This was the little
town that we saw in its somber robes on that Sabbath morning."
The building which would be later known as Beecher Hall
wasn't yet complete when Sturtevant arrived in Jacksonville. One
of the earliest references to Illinois College in a 1831
publication describes the college as consisting of two buildings,
one of brick, the other a frame farmhouse. The brick building was
designed for recitation rooms, lodging of up to thirty students,
and a chapel large enough to accomodate two hundred people. A
farm of two hundred twenty eight acres belonging to the college
was in cultivation surrounding the buildings. The library was
said to contain between six to eight hundred volumes.
Sturtevant was solely in charge of the college until May 1830
when the trustees, in consultation with Yale President Day,
called the Reverend Mr. Edward Beecher to be the first President
of the College. Beecher had been until that time the pastor of
Park Street Church, Boston, Massachusetts. As a matter of
interest, Beecher was the son of Henry Ward Beecher and the
brother of Harriet Beecher Stowe. But, Beecher's term as
president would end in 1844. Sturtevant would then be back in
charge.
Classes at Illinois College began on Monday, January 4, 1830
with nine pupils in attendance, in a still incomplete building.
Sturtevant, then in full charge of the college, opened the
session with these words, "We are here today to open a fountain
where future generations may drink."
The college operated without a state charter until 1835.
Theron Baldwin worked dilligently at getting a charter for the
school. There was a bill introduced in the Illinois House in 1831
for this purpose which passed in the house, but failed in the
Senate. Baldwin wrote to Grosvenor, "No wolf or fox would tread
more carefully around a trap than do these men about our bill and
though no one of them probably knows how Troy was destroyed, yet
they appear to gather around this mysterious thing much as the
Trojans did about the horse." Why exactly there was such resistance
to granting the charter is unclear. Perhaps, as has been stated in
numerous letters between various members of the Yale Band dating from
this period, the State Senators feared that this would be an
uncomfortable blending of Church and State. Perhaps, it was a
matter, as suggested in several other letters
that the resistance was because of a fear of the college becoming
a facade for greedy land speculators. Whatever the cause, the
resistence in State government to granting a charter to the
college was only finally overcome with the aid of Governor
Duncan, whose home incidentally was less than a mile from the
college.
The enthusiasm which Illinois College engendered among its
early faculty is best shown by a letter written by Truman Post to
his mother on June 8, 1834, "I am associated with some of the
best men, intellectually and morally that I have ever seen, in a
spot that in beauty and fertility is the garden of the whole
west, in the midst of a community that will soon be immensely
rich and strong."
So, it is clear that the men who migrated from New England to
Illinois to found Illinois College did so out of their deep
seated religious convictions. As Sturtevant said, they had
established a fountain of knowledge from which future generations
could drink. Illinois College has educated clergymen, doctors,
lawyers, teachers, businessmen, and politicians during its long
history. It is truly a great legacy that these men left as a
result of their "speedy and energetic measures."
Primary Sources
Baldwin-Sturtevant Correspondence, Illinois College Archives. _
Very comprehensive collection of letters between these two
friends which reflect on college affairs and current events of
the day.
Cartwright, Peter. Autobiography New York:Hunt and Easton, 1857.
Gives another view of prairie preachers and early Illinois.
Compact of the Yale Band, original document, Illinois College
Archives.
The defining document, setting out the reasons behind their
coming to Illinois.
Miscellaneous Correspondence, Illinois College Archives.
Extremely revealing correspondence of members of the Yale Band
and early faculty.
Sturtevant, Julian M. Autobiography New York: Fleming Revel& Co.,
1896.
The life and work of Julian Sturtevant as seen by Julian
Sturtevant
Secondary Sources
Alvord, Clarence Walworth (ed.) The Centennial History of
Illinois. 5 volumes. Springfield, Illinois, published by
the Illinois Centennial Commission. 1918-1920.
A comprehensive work about the first century of Illinois History.
Valuable background source.
"Classes Began at IC 150 years ago Friday," Jacksonville Journal Courier, January 6, 1980, page 21._
An overview of the early years of Illinois College.
Frank, Charles E. Pioneer's Progress:Illinois College 1829-1979
Southern Illinois University Press. 1979.
Deals mostly with Illinois College as it was in 1979, with
retrospectives on the past.
Kafoid, Carrie Prudence, "Puritan Influences in the Formative
Years of Illinois History", Boston:Congregational Sunday
School Publishing Society, 1899.
Talks about the impact of New England Congregationalists on the
history of Illinois.
Magoun, George F. Asa Turner and His Times, Boston:
Congregational Sunday School Publishing Society, 1889.
Wonderful book about Asa Turner.
Patterson, R.W. "Early Society in Southern Illinois," a lecture
before the Chicago Historical Society, October 19, 1880.
Published in Chicago 1881.
Good work talking about life in early Illinois, including the
state of education at that time.
Peck, J.M. A Guide for Emmigrants, Containing Sketches of Illinois,
Missouri, and adjacent parts. Boston: Lincoln and Edmonds Publishers,
1831, partially reprinted in "Illinois College 1829-1979" Supplement to the Jacksonville Journal Courier October 18, 1979.
A good description of the college as it was in 1831.
Post, T.A. Truman Marcellus Post , Boston: Congregational
Sunday School Publishing Society, 1891.
A good look at the early faculty of Illinois College.
Rammelkamp, Charles H. Illinois College:A Centennial History 1829-1929
New Haven: Yale University Press, 1928.
Good source of information on early Illinois College history.
Sturtevant, Julian M. Sketch on Theron Baldwin Boston: Alfred
Mudge & Son Printers, 1875. Reprinted from The Congregational Quarterly for April and July 1875.
Good piece about Theron Baldwin by his friend. _
Yaeger, Iver F. Sesquicentennial Papers: Illinois College
Southern Illinois University Press: 1982.
Mostly about IC at the Sesquicentennial, but some history is
there as well.